Staff Review: Japanese Destroyer Captain – Tameichi Hara

9781591143840By Jim

I picked this book up simply because it was the only time I had seen a history of World War II told from the perspective of the Japanese. What I hadn’t realized is Hara’s Japanese Destroyer Captain was actually a much older book. It was originally published in the 1960s as Hara tried to help a younger generation of Japanese understand the war. The book I picked up was a 2011 reprint. It’s still well worth the read. Hara is one of those people you see in history who is on the fringes of major historical events doing his job efficiently and well. He isn’t a big name so no one notices him. Then you read his memoir and are shocked by all he saw.

Hara was born to a relatively poor family of samurai stock. He entered the navy and prior to the war gained notoriety for rewriting the destroyer torpedo manual for the Japanese navy. That is pretty impressive when you think of all of the Japanese destroyers who used torpedoes during World War II TameichiHarawere using his calculations. During the war itself Hara commanded two destroyers the Amatsukaze and the Shigure and made over a hundred sorties against the Americans and her allies. The book is full of hair raising stories of facing off in torpedo and gun duels with American destroyers and cruisers in the dead of night in the south Pacific. It also details many of the major actions of the war that he participated in including Midway and Guadalcanal. In spite of the subtitle he didn’t actually participate in the attack on Pear Harbor. His destroyer was assigned to the attack on the Philippines and the Dutch East Indies. There is even an account of the sinking of John F Kennedy’s PT-109. Hara’s ship was directly behind the destroyer that rammed the future president’s torpedo boat. You would almost miss it though since Hara doesn’t know that it was Kennedy’s boat and it’s just another day fighting in the Solomon Islands.

One of the best parts of this book is Hara’s analysis of the over all strategy and tactics of both the Americans and the Japanese during the war. He doesn’t play favorites. He is quick to point out the failings of fellow captains and his own commanders and government as he is the failings of the American Navy. He even turns his criticism on himself. In short it’s a fascinating perspective on a part of the war that many American’s think they know.

The Japanese Destroyer Shigure

The Japanese Destroyer Shigure

Advertisements

One thought on “Staff Review: Japanese Destroyer Captain – Tameichi Hara

  1. I really enjoyed this book. It was a unique first hand account of the war from the Japanese perspective. I have read the Rising Sun (overall strategic accounting of the Japanese Empire) and Requiem for Battleship Yamato. With the hind sight of those books, I fully understand the failings of the Japanese way of fighting and the disadvantag of Bushido in modern war. As Tameichi Hara pointed out many times, the IJN was inflexible in its planning (both Army and Navy) and thus suffered needles losses.

    Hind sight also had me feeling sorry for Tameichi, as we now know that America had broken Japanese codes. He made specific mention that the Americans had great intel of their strength and movements, little did he know that it was because of our code breaking.

    Overall this is a great gem of a read, and everyone interested in the subject matter needs to read it. Great review!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s